Tuesday, October 12, 2010

George Bignell


Ever heard of George Bignell?

No? Maybe this will help: Bignell played four games for the old Milwaukee Brewers of the Union Association in 1884.

Still doesn't ring a bell? On October 3, 1884, Bignell set the record for most chances accepted in a game by a catcher with 23. The record has never been equaled.

Now got him?

No? Well, me either. Before I started researching him, I had never heard of the man. Of course, this raises the question: Why research him?

The answer: Because I recently ran across this photo at the New York Public Library's Digital Gallery web site:


New York Public Library Digital Gallery, Image ID: 55702

The photograph is identified as "George Brynan" and is listed under the subject of "baseball." But a quick check of any baseball encyclopedia will reveal that just one person named Brynan ever played in the big leagues: Charles Ruley "Tod" Brynan. Indeed, there doesn't appear to have been a "George Brynan" who played at any level of professional baseball.

Like Bignell, Tod Brynan played just four games in his major league career, pitching in the National League for Chicago (three games in 1888) and Boston (one game in 1891). Coincidentally, an image of Tod Brynan is also available at the New York Public Library's Digital Gallery web site. Alas, the NYPL has misidentified Tod Brynan as George Brynan. Here is that image:


New York Public Library Digital Gallery, Image ID: 55700

Note that at the bottom of the photograph is written "C. BRYNAN. P, CHICAGO." The image is actually of an Old Judge tobacco card of Brynan issued in 1888, part of what is referred to in the card collecting hobby as the N173 set. A similar card was sold at Legendary Auctions in August of 2010 for a whopping $1,777.50.

While there is some similarity between Tod Brynan in the N173 photo and the player in the head-and-shoulders photograph, a more obvious clue caused me to question the identification of the latter image. Take a look at the reverse of that photo portrait:


New York Public Library Digital Gallery, Image ID: 55702

Below and to the right of the New York Public Library stamp is a handwritten name: George Bignall. Below that name is a notation that appears to be an attempt to decipher the handwritten last name ... a rather poor attempt: Brynan. While the latter name was added to the NYPL database, it was the former name that I thought was more likely to be correct. I failed to find a big leaguer named Bignall, but big leaguer George Bignell was pretty close.

The next step was to contact the Pictorial History Committee (PHC) of the Society for American Baseball Research. The Committee's Player Image Index project is an attempt to catalog at least one image of every major league ballplayer. The entry for George Bignell was supplied by ace baseball researcher and New England baseball expert Bob Richardson, who found the following woodcut in the October 10, 1885 issue of the Brockton Gazette of Brockton, Massachusetts:



The image above was clearly based on the photo found at the New York Public Library's Digital Gallery web site. Additionally, the Bignell photo was taken at Bass Photo Studio in Brockton, while the woodcut was published in the Brockton Gazette.

There's really no question: the NYPL photo identified as George Brynan is actually one of former major league catcher George Bignell.

5 comments:

  1. Another excellent article! I'm so happy to have stumbled upon this blog.

    I hope I'm not out of line in pointing out, however, a small item of English usage that a person with your obvious eye for detail might find interesting: The phrase "this begs the question" (used near the top of this post) is entirely different in meaning from "this raises the question" (this latter phrase seems to have been your intended meaning).

    See the following links for a full explanation.

    http://begthequestion.info/
    http://goo.gl/dg1g

    ReplyDelete
  2. Brian -
    Thanks for the comment and for the lesson in English usage. I've made the change to the blog entry.
    - Tom

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Tom - I'm Tod Brynan's great grand daughter. You are correct. The one labelled George Brynan is NOT correct. I've run across that error so many times, but I guess it's impossible to truly and finally correct it on the 'net. The Old Judge card of Charles (Tod) Brynan you have pictured here is definately my great grand father. I have similar photos of him hanging on my walls!
    Carole

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Tom - I'm Tod Brynan's great grand daughter. You are correct. The one labelled George Brynan is NOT correct. I've run across that error so many times, but I guess it's impossible to truly and finally correct it on the 'net. The Old Judge card of Charles (Tod) Brynan you have pictured here is definately my great grand father. I have similar photos of him hanging on my walls!
    Carole

    ReplyDelete
  5. An interesting feature of the Tod Brynan photo are the padded kneecaps on his uniform. I have never seen such padding before - was it something that Brynan did just for himself? Why would a pitcher need padding on his knees - maybe Brynan's action lead to him falling over on the mound?

    ReplyDelete